Emergency grower meetings held in British Columbia's Okanagan Valley last week culminated in the decision that supply management may be the only way the orchard industry can survive collapsing prices.
The meetings were triggered by receipt of the first advances from the Okanagan Tree Fruit Co-operative for last year's crop of apples and the realization that returns were even lower than the previous year.
B.C. Fruit Growers Association president Joe Sardinha says the meetings were "very emotional."
"There was clear direction from growers. We were told to tell government that orchardists need what the supply management folks have -- a regulated marketing system. It's the only way the industry will survive," he says.
Meetings have been requested with the federal and provincial governments for support in reaching both a short-term and a long-term solution to the problem.
In the short term, Sardinha says growers need an emergency payment to continue looking after their orchards in the face of a price collapse. In the long term, a supply management system is needed.
"We're receiving 1970s returns and paying 2010 costs," he summarized. "I'm not happy. I'm frustrated, anxious, disappointed and I'm angry."
Jim Elliot, a producer and president of the co-operative, says he never expected prices for apples to drop as low as they have this year.
"They're far below what is needed for sustainability," he admits. "There's not much of a profit margin in the orchard industry. If prices are down 10 per cent, our margins could be down 50 per cent. The value of my crop barely covers my bill for hired labour and I grow 1,300 bins of apples. That's not counting mine and my family's labour on the farm."
Despite the fact Okanagan orchards are among the most modern in the world, there's just no stability in markets, he points out.
Growers must continue to prune, spray, thin, water and pick, even if there's no market for fruit. Otherwise, he explains, they lose their entire investment in new trees. That upkeep costs and growers don't have the money when they don't get sufficient returns from the previous year's crop. And, Elliot notes, this is the second year of poor returns.
Low prices are blamed on the strong Canadian dollar which has impacted exports. Also, a world oversupply of apples, particularly in Washington State, has brought prices down in Canada. Last year, Washington State's apple crop was 102 million boxes, compared to 3.2 million from B.C.
Sardinha says it's an uneven playing field. American growers are subsidized by a federal export enhancement program, lower production costs and other government programs that use local fruit as the school nutrition program, a food stamps-type program and a 100 per cent local procurement policy.




